Conversion-Centered Redesign: Slash the Risk and Guarantee Results

Brian Massey presents five design case studies and how to use conversion-centered redesign to reduce risk and deliver revenue growth quickly.

What You’ll Learn

  • Why redesigns fail
  • Justifying the risk and effort of a redesign
  • Key redesign metrics to watch
  • Five redesign case studies

What JJ Knows

JJ Abrams has successfully rebooted three marquee movie franchises in his career: Mission Impossible, Star Trek and now Star Wars.

He seems to know something that we need to understand when we redesign our websites: what to keep in his reboots and what create from scratch.

Watch the Webinar Now


Why Redesigns Fail

  • Repeat Visitors are Shocked
  • Designed for Wrong Segments
  • Your Audience Has Several
  • Local Maxima
  • Your Visitors Didn’t Go to the Same Design School.
  • Reliance on Best Practices
  • Too Much Emphasis on Look and Feel

Typical (Bad) Reasons to Redesign

  • Change in Management
  • You have a poor performing website.
  • Need a better mobile experience
  • “Well, just look at it!”
  • “We need to be unique!”

Good Reasons to Redesign

There are only two good reasons for a website redesign:

  1. The platform or content management system (CMS) we built on sucks.
  2. We’re completely rebranding our company or product line.

Five Redesign Strategies to Choose From

  • Going All In
  • Test on Old Site
  • Use Old Site to Inform New Site
  • Launch Side-by-side
  • Conversion-centered Redesign

Read the full conversion–centered redesign case study.

Place Your Bets

These are the areas in which you make assumptions when you “go all in”. Many of your choices can increase performance. Many will not.

  • The Right Value Proposition
  • The Right Calls to Action
  • The Right Copy and Images
  • The Expected Look and Feel
  • Trust Builders
  • Proof
  • Risk Reversal
  • All Website Changes

The Kinds of Information We Use to Make Design Decisions

When making these decisions, too many of us rely on information from categories 1 through 3 of this list. The least reliable sources are listed first.

  1. Informed Intuition (What I think works)
  2. Self-reported Input (What others make up about what works)
  3. Best Practices Experience (What works for other sites)
  4. Qualitative Behavioral Data (What works for small numbers of visitors)
  5. Quantitative Behavioral Data (What works for statistically valid groups of visitors)

I give examples of each of these and explain why they are or are not reliable.

21 Quick and Easy CRO Copywriting Hacks to Skyrocket Conversions

21 Quick and Easy CRO Copywriting Hacks

Keep these proven copywriting hacks in mind to make your copy convert.

  • 43 Pages with Examples
  • Assumptive Phrasing
  • "We" vs. "You"
  • Pattern Interrupts
  • The Power of Three
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Metrics We Watch

When you launch your redesign, these metrics will tell you if your redesign was successful or not.

  • Returning Users: Are probably in the Consideration Phase or Action Phase
  • Lead Generation: Did we make it harder for visitors to take action?
  • Lead Quality
  • Lead Close Ratio
  • Lead Score
  • Lead Pipeline Stage
  • Conversion Rate
  • Average Order Value
  • Lead Value
  • Revenue per Visit
  • Conversion by Traffic Source

Compare these metrics before and after the launch. You should also compare the year-over-year results to eliminate seasonal effects.

Things to Test on Current Site

If you are going to test things on your existing site to inform your redesign, consider these “portable” solutions:

  • Value Proposition Language
  • Calls to Action
  • Risk Reversal
  • Trust Builders
  • Landing Pages
  • Form Length

Be Ready to Go Back

If possible, always be ready to roll back to your old site if the new one craters sales.


We often redesign for the wrong reasons.

Without data, redesigns are risky.
Without data, redesigns are risky. The “Going All In” is the most risky and most common. Collecting analytics data on the current site mitigates the risk. Testing assumptions on the current site further reduces risk. A side-by-side launch approach allows you to back out poor performing features. A stepwise approach eliminates risk while increasing performance immediately.

Do you need a conversion-centered redesign or an optimization program?

Conversion Sciences Redesign Lab™ delivers the data and test results for…

  1. Redesigns that guarantee success.
  2. Deliver increasing monthly revenues over 180 days.
  3. Completely turnkey. We provide data scientists, designers and developers.

Contact us to schedule a call. We’ll discuss your goals and strategies for your site.
Brian Massey



Photo Credit: (cc)

Brian Massey
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *